Google Reviews View All
Andrew Klein
From a different town and went to go see newphews basketball game, so we stop in at patio pizza after because we definitely wanted to eat outside. Ordered a Regular Pie some garlic knots. I tell ya I never ate 3 slices until today. This place makes sause just like my grandmother's. Simply amazing pizza cooked just right. Service was awesome, and the locals that ate there were so friendly. I recommend anyone passing by St. James to go to this place.
Tracy Lent
Great friendly staff make all the difference, elevating this local spot. Good old school Italian food.. great outdoor seating, open atmosphere, some shade umbrellas.
Yelp Reviews View All
Jill L.
2025-03-12 20:45:23
The pizza pie was dry and bland. I couldn't taste the sauce because I couldn't really find it to taste and then it was dry and hard to get through. I just...
Louis S.
2024-10-27 16:02:48
It's super clean and the workers are so kind. It supports trump which makes it even better. The food tastes amazing and the quality is great! Most of the...
Melissa F.
2024-10-27 10:17:29
I used to come here all the time. Just tried it the other day. Pizza was not very good. Very skimpy on toppings and tasted old.
Gary F.
2024-10-22 06:42:58
LOVE this place. food always cooked perfectly, service is great and the ambiance is what you'd expect from a small town pizzeria (great)... cant wait to go...
Louis S.
2024-08-14 15:53:47
The people here are amazing the owner is so kind and the food is amazing. It was comfortable and quick it was nice and quiet.
Donna R.
2024-06-20 17:49:05
I take my elderly mother every Saturday for lunch to The Patio. The owner Guy is so friendly and personable. The food is amazing. The restaurant is very...
Trump S.
2024-04-14 08:34:27
They display their support for police on their walls but yet must not support the Capital Police from Jan 6th. This place has Trump patio night ever...
Brianna D.
2024-02-25 11:39:27
The BEST Most amazing Italian I've had in a long time. Will not go to any other pizzeria. The eggplant dinner is phenomenal.Minestrone soup is AMAZING!...
Scott F.
2024-02-18 14:59:38
Had a party catered today from them, notThe first time and certainly won't be the last. The food was excellent, never a disappointment!! Delivered hot and...
Mike M.
2023-10-24 18:19:01
Great food and service. Guy and his team does a really great job in making the customers very happy.
Bill C.
2023-10-22 01:40:31
this place made my stomach hurt so bad and I was passing gas for hours. My friend works there and he said the kitchen is so dirty. don't believe this food...
Jim K.
2023-10-20 07:20:39
I love this place and go here for seafood. You get a good honest meal here. The staff is always very good, I always look forward to going here. I expect it...
Matt M.
2023-10-06 09:46:44
Excellent pizza. Service is always fast. This is our new pizzeria after living in Smithtown over 30 years
Liz L.
2023-09-13 04:21:46
My husband loves it and I cannot find the pleasure of other people enjoying this mess. Add on prices are ridiculous, obnoxious political crowd outside (when...
Maria E.
2023-09-02 19:40:55
Trumper infested pizza place. Do not recommend their pizza or giving a dime to this place.
Debra D.
2023-06-09 10:16:19
The best pizza anywhere. Full selection of entrees. Great homemade salad dressing . Amazing service, kind people, really impressive commitment to the craft....
John Z.
2023-05-20 08:03:46
Yummy! The best sauce, everything is delicious and the staff and owner are so nice! The pizza is so good and everything is fresh
Peggy L.
2022-07-25 16:24:55
Plain tasting pizza. Nothing special but the patio and live music are really nice! Baked clams said 6 clams on the menu but only 4 came out of the kitchen!...
Symone F.
2022-04-04 12:48:38
We ordered the chicken franchise, chicken parmigiana and a side order of meatballs. The chicken franchise was amazing. The sauce was perfectly lemony and...
Paul B.
2021-06-23 14:14:54
My first time here had a glorious chicken parm hero.What I noticed right away was the heftiness of how it felt....some places skimp on take out heroes -...